Does the installer size matter for you?

Post Reply

5 MBs is appropriate size for USB Safely Remove's installer?

No, you should decrease it
2
6%
Yes, it's OK
10
32%
Yes, it's OK and you can even increase it
19
61%
 
Total votes: 31
User avatar
Igor
Developer
Posts: 562
Joined: Nov 1st, 2007, 12:44 pm
Location: Saint Petersburg
Contact:

Does the installer size matter for you?

Post by Igor » Oct 11th, 2008, 6:54 pm

Installer size of USB Safely Remove may be grown up to 5 MB due to adding of help files, additional components and etc. It's quite likely that users who are using the program and know its value won't pay their attention on the installer size.

So it is interesting to know your opinion on this theoretical question: does the program size matter at the point when you are not known with a program.

Let's suppose that you are unfamiliar with USB Safely Remove and come upon "a utility that extends Safely Remove Hardware function". You do not know if this program is useful just for you or not. So would you download such utility just "to see what is it" if it weighs 5MB? And what about 10MB?
mysteryman
Posts: 17
Joined: Dec 31st, 2007, 8:33 am

Post by mysteryman » Oct 12th, 2008, 5:37 am

It is a much better idea to put this surplus information into a secondary download. You should offer two downloads. One with english, offering to download additional languages remotely during install, and a second tagged multilang.

Help files for many languages is a waste of time/bw for all people INCLUDING your own webserver. Hosting is not free afterall. People generally only need one language, regardless of which one they prefer. You can obviously add a few more single-language downloads as needed, For everybody else, it's easy enough to click a checkbox during install.

However there are other reasons that cause this to be a bad idea. For me, I look at the program and say... that should take up 1-2MB, I get to the download page... and then 'holy crap, its 20MB.... what did they sneak in there.' At very least, I might run it in VM before hand, others might skip it entirely.

With 20MB of space, or even the more conservative 5-10MB ... the program could potentially contain any number of malware. Granted, it does not... but the person wont know without downloading it.

Even if the user had a bit of faith (or oblivious) about malware, they might be concerned that a program that runs all the time might actually be USING 10-20M. Again, it does not... the main exe is <1.5M and running memory <6M on my pc, with all dlls etc. Though, I don't usually flinch under 100MB as long as it is a trusted application, and sounds reasonable for the type of application; others might.

Also, this is coming from someone who downloads dozens of gigabytes on a whim. People on dialup will obviously have another reason as well. A friend of mine was visiting family and was stuck with dialup for a few months. he wouldn't even take the time to download necessary things like adobe reader, or winamp because it took too long. Granted, adobe is huge (I convinced him to try foxit)... but winamp is not.

In summary... yes you could make it a hair bigger, but don't go crazy, and try to make the unneeded information modular during install (not included until needed). Also, if you do go making a huge multi-lang package... make a english only package to give some perspective to people downloading.
GregDude
Posts: 4
Joined: Feb 26th, 2010, 3:19 am

Re: Does the installer size matter for you?

Post by GregDude » Mar 2nd, 2010, 6:01 am

We're talking only 5 to 10mb here, for people who most likely own > 1gb USB drive, have internet connection and exist in the year 2010. Ask us again when the installer reaches 1gb, though we'd be more interested in what you managed to pack in it, perhaps a DVD quality training video in all languages ;)
Post Reply